In the heart of the subcontinent, during a time of rising confusion and religious deviation, a spiritual giant stepped forward to defend the integrity of Islam. Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah of Golra Sharif, a revered scholar and Sufi saint, played a pivotal role in confronting the controversial claims of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian — founder of the Ahmadiyya (Qadiani) movement.
A Divine Mission Foretold
In 1890, while performing Hajj, Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah experienced a deep spiritual awakening in the sacred lands of Makkah and Madinah. He even considered settling permanently in Hijaz. But a seasoned spiritual guide, Haji Imdadullah Muhajir Makki, gave him a prophetic warning:
“A dangerous movement will soon emerge in India. You have a crucial role to play in combating it.”
Within a year, the prediction materialized. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian announced that he was the Promised Messiah — a claim that later evolved into a claim of prophethood.
Spiritual Visions and a Call to Action
Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah was not only intellectually equipped, but spiritually guided. In one powerful dream, the Holy Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) instructed him to oppose Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, who was accused of distorting the Prophet’s teachings.
In another vision, Hazrat saw himself humbly sitting before the Prophet (PBUH), while Mirza sat with his back turned — a symbol of arrogance and deviation. These visions ignited his resolve to publicly confront the Qadiani movement.
The First Encounter with Qadianism
The first direct interaction came when Mirza’s follower, Maulvi Abdul Karim of Sialkot, sent Hazrat a letter asking for support. In it, Mirza claimed to be the Promised Messiah, tasked by God to revive Islam.
Hazrat replied firmly: he did not recognize Mirza’s claim and advised him to focus on spreading Islam — not self-proclaimed spiritual titles.
A Bold Challenge to the Spiritual Elite
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, frustrated by rejection from the country’s spiritual leaders, issued an audacious challenge:
“Let all who call themselves scholars, saints, or mystics come forward and face me — if they dare.”
Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah accepted the challenge. But he wasn’t alone — leading Islamic scholars from all backgrounds stood behind him.
Shams-ul-Hidayah: A Scholarly Thunderbolt
In 1899, Hazrat wrote Shams-ul-Hidayah, a brilliant scholarly work in Q&A format. In it, he refuted Mirza’s ideas — particularly the claim that Jesus (Isa A.S) had died a natural death. Hazrat provided robust evidence from the Qur’an and Hadith proving that Jesus had been raised alive and would return before the Day of Judgment.
This book shook Qadian to its core. Mirza’s closest ally, Hakim Nuruddin, scrambled to reply but instead posed unrelated counter-questions, hoping to divert the issue. Hazrat answered all of them — and then asked just one question in return: “Explain the reality of miracles.”
They never answered.
The Historic Challenge: A Public Showdown
Mirza, still seeking legitimacy, challenged Hazrat to a Quran commentary contest in Arabic. It was to be held in Lahore in July 1900. Hazrat accepted without hesitation — and agreed to all of Mirza’s conditions. He even added an offer: before the writing contest, let there be an oral debate so both could publicly present their views.
Mirza declined.
Even then, Hazrat agreed to the original written contest. The date was set: 25th August 1900. Anticipation swept the nation.
Lahore: The City That Waited
On the appointed date, thousands gathered in Lahore. Scholars, students, religious leaders, and laypeople from across India came to witness the showdown. The air was electric with expectation.
Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah arrived with great humility, despite massive support. But Mirza? He never showed up.
Two days passed. Still, no sign of him.
Hazrat’s supporters sent telegrams and waited patiently. Eventually, word came: Mirza refused to come. He claimed his life was in danger — though he himself had issued the challenge!
The absence spoke louder than any argument.
The Aftermath: Disappointment and Desperation
Mirza’s refusal stunned even his own followers. Some left the movement in disillusionment. Others tried to spin the story, falsely claiming Pir Meher Ali Shah had fled Lahore. But the truth was known: he had come, he had waited, and his opponent had not.
Later, Mirza proposed a new contest — each side would write an Arabic commentary on Surah Al-Fatiha from their respective hometowns. Hazrat refused, seeing it as another evasive tactic. He had already honored his word.
Saif-e-Chishtiyai: The Final Blow
In response to Mirza’s failed claims and writings, Hazrat wrote his masterwork Saif-e-Chishtiyai (The Chishtia Sword). It was a scathing academic refutation of Mirza’s Arabic commentaries, pointing out grammatical errors, logical flaws, and theological deviations.
He predicted that Mirza would never be able to visit Madinah or perform Hajj — duties the real Messiah would fulfill. Mirza died shortly afterward, without ever stepping foot in the holy city or performing pilgrimage.
Legacy and Lasting Impact
Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah’s courageous stance lit a fire in the hearts of Muslims across the subcontinent. His work laid the foundation for the movement that ultimately led to the Pakistani Parliament’s historic decision in 1974 — officially declaring the Qadiani community outside the fold of Islam.
Despite attempts by Ahmadi missionaries abroad to disguise their beliefs under the banner of Islam, the truth remains preserved — thanks in large part to the unyielding efforts of Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah and other committed scholars.
Conclusion
Hazrat Pir Meher Ali Shah didn’t just refute a man — he defended a faith. He faced down distortion with dignity, stood for truth over convenience, and remained loyal to the legacy of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
Today, his life and legacy stand as a towering example of what it means to be a scholar, a saint, and a soldier of faith — all in one.
Post a Comment